She was guessing he meant first contact in general,  given that she couldn't have been the first that he'd come across in the time that he'd  been there, despite the fact that she'd found him talking to himself. Right?

When he denied being related to Tony, Lucy smiled and explained. "Sorry, there's a guy here.  Same..."

She trailed off and made a vague motion at her face as if to indicate the two of them shared the same kind of facial hair.